What certainty teaches
نویسنده
چکیده
Most philosophers, including all materialists I know of, believe that I am a complex thing—a thing with parts—and that my mental life is (or is a result of) the interaction of these parts. These philosophers often believe that I am a body or a brain, and my mental life is (or is a product of) brain activity. In this paper, I develop and defend a novel argument against this view. The argument turns on certainty, that highest epistemic status that a precious few of our beliefs enjoy. For example, on the basis of introspection, I am certain that I am not in fierce pain right now. But if I am a complex thing like a body or a brain, then introspection might be a causal series of events extended in time. And any such process could go awry. So, if introspection is such a process, then I could gain good evidence that the introspective process has gone awry and that I am, contrary to appearances, feeling fierce pain right now. Therefore, the view that I am a complex thing like a body or a brain forces open the possibility that I cannot be certain that I am not feeling fierce pain right now. Since that is clearly not an open possibility, it follows that I am not a complex thing. I conclude by responding to three objections.
منابع مشابه
Assessing Self-awareness and Transparency when Classifying a Speaker’s Level of Certainty
This paper is about using prosody to automatically detect one aspect of a speaker’s internal state: their level of certainty. While past work on classifying level of certainty used the perceived level of certainty as the value to predict, we find that this quantity often differs from a speaker’s actual level of certainty as gauged by self-reports. In this work we build models to predict a speak...
متن کاملWhat Teaching Teaches: Mentoring and the Performance Gains of Mentors
and keywords Full text (PDF) with links to cited JCE articles
متن کاملWhat Determines Human Certainty?
Previous work on concept learning has focused on how concepts are acquired without addressing metacognitive aspects of this process. An important part of concept learning from a learner’s perspective is subjectively knowing when a new concept has been effectively learned. Here, we investigate learners’ certainty in a classic Boolean concept-learning task. We collected certainty judgements durin...
متن کاملLegal Certainty and Contract Arrangements
Legal certainty is a fundamental principle which contributes in the rule of law. According to some authors this principle is an “imperative necessity for the European Union”. Indeed the European case-law recognized the principle of legal certainty. One the one hand, through the European Court of Justice in 1962 in the Bosch judgment. As well, the principle of legitimate expectations – which is ...
متن کامل